We have our winners!
No, we didn't forget!
Nettlejuice was chosen twice. First by Madeleine because of her name :) (good call, April) and secondly by Trev because she has a son who loves prehistory and dinosaurs. ([shrug] I can't help it. He's partial.)
So Madd chose next (because Trev didn't want to choose again - he was too busy, and he insisted that he was claiming April/Nettlejuice and dinosaurs), and she chose Heart Rockin Mama! (from the pictures in the comments)
This was three days ago, and just today we finally put the names in a -PeterPan- hat...
First chosen was Sam!
and then Rinnyboo!
and finally Mary at Attachlings.
We'll (I will) be actively thinking and making very soon!